Proton
nsa cyberattack wannacry ransomware

Important lessons from the first NSA-powered ransomware cyberattack

Last Friday, a weaponized version of a NSA exploit was used to infect over three hundred thousand computers in over 150 countries with the WannaCry ransomware.

In addition to government ministries and transportation infrastructure, the British National Health Service (NHS) was crippled, disrupting treatment and care for thousands of patients, and putting countless lives at risk(nuova finestra). The indiscriminate use of a NSA authored weapon on the general public is terrifying, and only made worse by the fact that the NSA could have largely prevented the attack. Instead, because the NSA stood by and did nothing, we have ended up in the scary world where American cyberweapons are being used to potentially kill British citizens in their hospital beds.

What went wrong?

The WannaCry infection that caused global chaos on Friday(nuova finestra) relied upon a Windows exploit called EternalBlue (nuova finestra)which was originally written by the NSA. Instead of responsibly disclosing the vulnerability when it was discovered, the NSA instead weaponized it and sought to keep it secret, believing that this weapon could be safely kept hidden.

Predictably, this was not the case, and in August 2016, the NSA was itself compromised(nuova finestra), and their entire arsenal of illicit cyberweapons stolen. It’s rather ironic that the world’s largest surveillance agency believed that they would never be compromised.

It has become abundantly clear over the past decade that the notion of keeping attackers out forever is fundamentally flawed. Compromises are not a matter of if, but a matter of when(nuova finestra) (in fact, this is why we designed Proton Mail to be the first email service that can protect data even in the event of a compromise). If there’s anybody that should know this, it should be the NSA.

NHS trust ransomware wannacry
Hospitals across the UK suffered major IT malfunctions as a result of the ransomware cyberattack.

It gets even worse

It’s clear that in weaponizing a vulnerability instead of responsibly disclosing it (so hospitals and transportation infrastructure can be protected), the NSA made a critical error in judgment that put millions of people at risk. However, one would think that after learning 10 months ago that their entire cyberweapon arsenal had been stolen and was now out “in the wild”, the NSA would have immediately taken action and responsibly disclosed the vulnerabilities so systems around the world could be patched.

Unfortunately, there is no indication that they did so. If we read carefully the statement from Microsoft today(nuova finestra), it appears the NSA deliberately withheld the information that would have allowed critical civilian infrastructure like hospitals to be protected. In our view, this is unforgiveable and beyond irresponsible.

Instead, the Windows engineering team was left to work by themselves to find the vulnerabilities, which they finally did in March 2017, 8 months after the NSA learned the exploits had been stolen. More critically, Microsoft only managed to patch the vulnerabilities 2 months before last Friday’s attacks, which is not nearly enough time for all enterprise machines to be updated.

wannacry ransomware infection map

What is the bigger impact?

We think that US Congressman Ted Lieu is spot on when he wrote on Friday(nuova finestra): “Today’s worldwide ransomware attack shows what can happen when the NSA or CIA write malware instead of disclosing the vulnerability to the software manufacturer.”

Friday’s attack is a clear demonstration of the damage that just a SINGLE exploit can do. If we have learned anything from the NSA hack(nuova finestra), and the more recent CIA Vault7 leaks(nuova finestra), it’s that potentially hundreds of additional exploits exist, many targeting other platforms, not just Microsoft Windows. Furthermore, many of these are probably already out “in the wild” and available to cybercriminals.

At this point, the NSA and CIA have a moral obligation to responsibly disclose all additional vulnerabilities. We would say that this goes beyond just a moral obligation. When your own cyber weapons are used against your own country(nuova finestra), there is a duty to protect and defend, and responsible disclosure is now the only way forward.

Lessons Learned

Anybody working in online security will tell you that protecting against the bad guys is hard enough. The last thing we need is for the supposed “good guys” to be wreaking havoc. An undisclosed vulnerability is effectively a “back door” into supposedly secure computing environments, and as Friday’s attack aptly demonstrates, there is no such thing as a back door that only lets the good guys in.

This is the same fundamental issue that makes calls for encryption backdoors counterproductive(nuova finestra) and irresponsible. Despite repeated warnings from security industry experts, government officials in both the US(nuova finestra) and the UK(nuova finestra) have repeatedly called for encryption backdoors, which could grant special access into end-to-end encrypted systems like Proton Mail(nuova finestra).

However, Friday’s attacks clearly demonstrate that when it comes to security, there can be no middle ground. You either have security, or you don’t, and systems with backdoors in them are just fundamentally insecure. For this reason, we are unwilling to compromise(nuova finestra) on our position of no encryption backdoors, and we will continue to make our cryptography open source(nuova finestra) and auditable to ensure that there are no intentional or unintentional backdoors.

We firmly believe this is the only way forward in a world where cyberattacks are becoming increasingly common and more and more damaging, both economically and as a threat to democracy itself.

If you would like to support the work that the Proton Mail project is doing, you can upgrade to a paid plan(nuova finestra). Thank you for your support!

You can also get a free secure email account from Proton Mail here(nuova finestra).

Articoli correlati

how to write a professional email
en
Easy steps and examples for writing a professional email. See how Proton Mail can make your emails stand out.
Email etiquette: What it is and why it matters |
en
Find out what email etiquette is with key rules and examples, why it is important, and how Proton Mail can help.
A cover image for a blog about how to create an incident response plan that shows a desktop computer and a laptop with warning signs on their screens
en
Do you have an incident response plan to protect your business from financial and reputational damage? Find out how Proton Pass for Business can help you stay safe.
Shared with me in Proton Drive for desktop user interface
en
  • Per le aziende
  • Aggiornamenti dei prodotti
  • Proton Drive
We've improved Proton Drive for Windows to make it easier to securely collaborate with others from your desktop.
Smart glasses that have been modified for facial surveillance and dox you in real time, finding your personal information after seeing your face.
en
Students modified smart glasses to find someone’s personal data after just looking at them. This is why we must minimize data collection.
The cover image for a blog explaining what password encryption is and how Proton Pass helps users with no tech experience benefit from it
en
Password encryption sounds complicated, but anyone can benefit from it. We explain what it is and how it’s built into Proton Pass for everyone to use.