Proton Authenticator homepage

The pros and cons of biometric authentication

With biometric verification, the press of a thumbprint, the sound of a voice, or the shape of a face is all it takes to access a device or account.

Here's how biometric authentication works, where it falls short, and what it means for your privacy.

What is biometric authentication?

Authentication methods can be broken down into three types: 

  • Something you know, like a password or PIN
  • Something you have, like a security token or device
  • Something you are, like a fingerprint or face scan

Biometric authentication falls into the “something you are” category, and mostly involves mapping physical features, although it can also include some behavioral elements like typing speed, or the height and angle you hold your phone. There are various types of authentication, but many of us rely on biometric authentication every day, using our faces to unlock our phones and make payments, or voice recognition to control home devices.

How does biometric authentication work?

Biometric authentication follows a four-stage process that converts your physical traits into a verifiable identity, without ever storing the raw biometric data itself.

Enrollment

When you set up fingerprint or face recognition, your device captures a biometric sample, such as a fingerprint scan or a 3D map of your face. This sample is captured locally on your device, not uploaded to a server.

Feature extraction

The system analyzes the sample and extracts unique characteristics, such as the ridges of a fingerprint or the spatial geometry of a face. These features are converted into a mathematical template; a string of numbers that represents your biometric traits without containing an actual image.

Secure storage

The template is stored securely, typically in a dedicated hardware chip on your device. The actual fingerprint or face scan is discarded. Only the mathematical representation is retained, and it can't be reverse-engineered back into your original biometric.

Matching

Each time you authenticate, your device captures a new sample, extracts its features, and compares this with the stored template. If the similarity score exceeds a certain threshold, the authentication is successful. This process happens entirely on your device, in a matter of milliseconds.

Because biometric data never leaves your device and only a mathematical representation is stored, the risk of your fingerprint or face being stolen is significantly reduced.

Types of biometric authentication

Fingerprint recognition

Fingerprint or thumbprint authentication maps the unique ridges, whorls, and minutiae points on your fingertips. It’s commonly used to unlock devices and smart door locks, as well as by law enforcement and border control to verify identity. 

A newer alternative is finger vein authentication, which uses near-infrared (NIR) light to map the pattern of blood vessels beneath the skin's surface. Because vein patterns are internal and require a living pulse to detect, they're harder to spoof than surface fingerprints — making them particularly useful in high-security environments like banking and data centers.

Limitations: Surface fingerprints can be affected by dirt, moisture, dry skin, or minor injuries. They can also be replicated from lifted prints using sophisticated techniques, which is why finger vein authentication is gaining traction.

Facial recognition

Facial recognition maps the geometric layout of your face — the distance between your eyes, the shape of your jawline, the depth of your eye sockets — and compares it against a stored template. Apple's Face ID uses infrared depth sensing to create a 3D map, making it significantly harder to fool than older 2D camera-based systems. Beyond unlocking phones, facial recognition is used in airport security, surveillance in public spaces, and increasingly in retail and payment systems.

Limitations: Compared with other biometric methods, facial recognition can easily be used without the subject's knowledge or consent.

Iris authentication

Iris authentication maps the intricate patterns of the iris (the colored ring around your pupil) using NIR photography. These patterns are highly individual and remain stable throughout your life, making iris recognition one of the most accurate biometric methods available. Retina scanning, a related but distinct technology, maps the unique pattern of blood vessels at the back of the eye. Both are used in high-security environments such as military facilities, government buildings, and national ID programs.

Limitations: These methods typically require specialized hardware beyond a standard smartphone camera, which limits widespread consumer adoption. Iris recognition can be affected by certain eye conditions, reflections from glasses, or wearing colored contact lenses.

Voice recognition

Voice recognition analyzes the physiological characteristics of your vocal tract — the shape of your mouth, throat, and nasal passages — which produce a unique acoustic signature. It's distinct from speech recognition (which transcribes what you say rather than identifying who’s saying it). Voice authentication is commonly used in telephone banking, customer service systems, and smart home devices like Alexa, Siri, and Google Home.

Limitations: Voice can be affected by illness, background noise, or emotional state. More critically, advances in AI-generated voice cloning have made it easier to spoof voiceprints using short audio samples, raising security concerns for systems that rely on voice alone.

Behavioral biometrics

Unlike physical biometrics, which are generally checked just once at the start of a session, behavioral biometrics use AI and machine learning to monitor behavior over periods of time. These behaviors might include typing speed and pressure, patterns in mouse and touchscreen usage, the angle a phone is held at or the hand used, and walking or movement patterns. Behavioral biometrics are used primarily in fraud detection and continuous authentication — quietly running in the background to flag anomalies during an active session.

Limitations: Behavioral patterns can shift with context; stress, fatigue, injury, or even a new keyboard can alter how you type. There are also significant privacy implications, since continuous behavioral monitoring collects data about users on an ongoing basis rather than just at a single point of authentication, enabling a highly sensitive and unique profile to be built on the user.

Advantages of biometric authentication

There are plenty of advantages to using biometric verification, which is why it’s one of the most popular methods of logging in or proving your identity.

  • Convenience: There's nothing to create, remember, or store; you simply present your face or fingerprint and gain access.

  • Speed: Verification can take less than a second, making it faster than typing a password or retrieving a code from an authenticator app.

  • Resistance to phishing: Hackers can't trick you into sharing your fingerprint the way they can a password, and biometric data can't be entered into a fake login page.

  • Non-transferability: You can't accidentally share your fingerprint the way you might reuse or leak a password.

  • Accessibility: Biometric verification removes barriers for users who find passwords, PINs, or typing difficult, reducing reliance on memory and fine motor skills.

Disadvantages of biometric authentication

The disadvantages of biometrics aren’t extensive. But that’s not to say things can’t go wrong:

  • Irreversibility: If your fingerprint is compromised, you can't reset it the way you would a password.

  • Data breach risk: If biometric templates are stolen, the consequences are permanent and potentially affect every system where you use that biometric in the present and the future. 

  • Accuracy limitations: False rejections lock out legitimate users, while false positives risk granting access to the wrong person.

  • Accessibility barriers: Injury, medical conditions, and environmental factors can prevent biometric authentication from working reliably.

  • Cost and hardware: Specialized sensors and secure storage requirements can make biometric systems impractical for smaller organizations.

Biometric authentication vs. other authentication methods

How does biometric authentication compare with other methods like passwords, authenticator apps, and hardware security keys? 

Comparison

Biometrics

Passwords

Authenticator apps

Hardware keys

Security

High

Medium

Very high

Very high

Convenience

Very high

High

Medium

High

Affordability

High

Very high

High

Medium

Revocability

No

Very high

Very high

High

Remember, the best method for secure access involves more than one authentication method. Combining authentication methods across categories exponentially increases your security, and is the reason two-factor authentication (2FA) or multi-factor authentication (MFA) are considered best-practice. A secure password manager and an authenticator app are essential to support your biometric authentication strategies.

How biometric authentication impacts your privacy

If biometric data is stored on your device rather than server-side, it’s a relatively secure authentication method. 

And even when it is collected and stored, many jurisdictions around the world — including the EU, UK, Brazil, South Africa, China, India, and Australia — classify biometric data as sensitive or special category data, giving it enhanced legal protection. However, these data protection laws only govern how organizations protect your biometric data; when it comes to protecting your devices, your biometrics may actually work against you.

Around the world, courts are increasingly ruling that law enforcement can compel you to unlock a device using biometrics, because pressing a finger or looking at a camera is treated as a physical act rather than testimony. The same legal systems generally protect passwords and PINs, which are considered "testimonial" and can’t be compelled. This means a device locked with Face ID may be legally easier to open without your consent than one locked with a passcode.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use biometric authentication with Proton Authenticator?
Can biometric data be stolen?
Is biometric authentication safer than a password?
What happens if my biometric data changes?